Suvarnabhumi » Two aviation fuel pipeline operators set to go in court
Sunday, July 20th, 2008A dispute between the two aviation fuel pipeline operators serving Suvarnabhumi Airport has escalated into a lawsuit filed by JP-One Asset Co against rival Thai Petroleum Pipeline Co Ltd (Thappline).
JP-One, a subsidiary of Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) listed Bangkok Aviation Fuel Services Plc (Bafs), is claiming 5.18 billion baht in compensation for alleged tort and violation of the Trade Competition Act.
Thappline, a subsidiary of PTT Plc, is named as a defendant along with its directors in the suit, filed in the Thanyaburi Provincial Court. The suit follows an earlier complaint JP-One had made to the Commerce Ministry, claiming that Thappline was engaged in price-dumping.
A source from JP-One said the suit centred on Thappline’s fee structure for transporting jet fuel to Suvarnabhumi Airport. JP-One claims its rival is charging fees below its actual service and investment costs, by maintaining the rates it charged at the now-closed Don Muang Airport.
The court documents claim that Thappline charges 22.47 satang a litre to transport fuel from Map Ta Phut via Si Racha and Lam Luk Ka to Suvarnabhumi, a distance of 241 kilometres. Charges for transporting fuel from Si Racha to Suvarnabhumi (171 km) are 17.92 satang per litre.
The rates are the same as those set for the Map Ta Phut-Don Muang and Si Racha-Don Muang routes respectively, even though the routes to Suvarnabhumi are 11 km longer.
JP-One claims, Thappline spent 1.6 billion baht to lay a new pipeline to Suvarnabhumi.
JP-One charges 17 satang per litre to transport fuel from its Chong Nonsi depot via Makkasan to Suvarnabhumi, a distance of 44 km. It spent 700 million baht on new infrastructure to serve Suvarnabhumi.
The source said the lawsuit named Thappline’s directors because its board set the prices. The Thappline board comprises representatives of oil companies, which are its clients and would directly benefit from low transport fees.
The JP-One executive says the fee structure will worsen Thappline’s existing accumulated loss of around 10 billion baht and debts.
The practice, he said, demonstrated Thappline’s intention to use ”predatory pricing” to eliminate competition by forcing JP-One to take on a financial burden that could put it out of business.
He said that if Thappline gained a monopoly on fuel transport, it would violate an International Air Transport Association standard that requires international airports to maintain dual fuel-supply systems for stability and security purposes.
In addition to claiming damages, JP-One is asking the court to order Thappline to increase its fees to 45.55 satang per litre for the Map Ta Phut-Suvarnabhumi route and to 29.72 satang from Si Racha.
Last month, JP-One filed a dumping complaint to the Commerce Ministry’s Competition Board against Thappline.
Thappline said in response that it was able to sell fuel at Suvarnabhumi at the Don Muang price because the distance to the new Bangkok airport from its depot in Lam Luk Ka, Pathum Thani, was nearly the same as to the former Bangkok Airport, Don Muang.
Related Topics
- Suvarnabhumi Airport – Thailand’s New International Airport
- PM Satisfies the Authorities’s Performance on Suppressing Narcotics
- First flights to Suvarnabhumi Airport Thailand
- Focus on Safety and Security at Suvarnabhumi Airport
- Suvarnabhumi Airport set to open on Sept 28, ( Thailand )
- THAI Air to Migrate to Suvarnabhumi Airport
- Tours of new Suvarnabhumi Airport terminals end Aug 15, 2006
- Budget airlines submit flight plans Aug 17, 2006
- Affirms readiness of Suvarnabhumi Airport by Transport Minister
- THAI Air downgrades security vigilance for domestic & international flights
- Suvarnabhumi Airport State Agencies affirmed system readiness
- PM eases Suvarnabhumi move timetable
- Security system & staff set ready for Suvarnabhumi international airport
- Decorating the gateway to Southeast Asia
- New Airport fees for Suvarnabhumi Airport
- Attractions around Suvarnabhumi Airport Prepared for Tourists
- Moving to Suvarnabhumi
- Novotel Suvarnabhumi Airport Hotel Opens
- Trial for International Flights completed successfully
- Air traffic system in Suvarnabhumi Airport in place
- No Ceremonies for Don Muang close
- Train connecting new international airport with central Bangkok to open next year
- Non-aviation services could make more revenue for AoT
- Sept 7, Check-in system at Suvarnabhumi Airport Testing
- Transport Minister to take ambassadors tour Suvarnabhumi Airport
- Nok Air starts early at new airport but opts out on big day
- Land price rises near Suvarnabhumi
- DCAP Confident Suvarnabhumi Airport will have Power
- Customs inspections speedy service at Suvarnabhumi Airport
- AOT seeks more foreign-denominated income
- Thai Airways, American Express contract with UN agencies
- Bangkok Airways early move to Suvarnabhumi, September 21, 2006
- Jobs accelerating in communities neighbouring Suvarnabhumi
- 46 Diplomats confident in Suvarnabhumi Airport’s capability
- CNN – New era for air travel
- “Suvarnabhumi Cash Card” to make traveling easier
- Suvarnabhumi Airport boosts investment
- Private sector confident Suvarnabhumi’s cargo hub potential
- Don Muang To Become Maintenance Hub
- Suvarnabhumi Airport aims for global accolades
- Jetstar to Land at Suvarnabhumi Airport Friday, September 15, 2006
- JAL to add flight after Suvarnabhumi Airport opens
- Thai Air starting first flight from Suvarnabhumi Airport today
- Thailand’s visa-free entry rules tighten
- Passengers on first commercial flights satisfied with Suvarnabhumi Airport
- Suvarnabhumi Airport completely prepared for 28 Sept. 2006
- Energy consumption to jump after Suvarnabhumi Airport opens
- No problem with holes in Suvarnabhumi Airport’s roof
- Bangkok Airways starts at Suvarnabhumi Airport on September 21, 2006
- Suvarnabhumi Airport opens on schedule